Xbox 360 Fanboy

Yeah, that's my concern. It was nice when the had the free Carcassonne too, but I already owned it! Thanks for nothing, Microsoft.

If they offer a specific game, and not a game of our choice, it would be completely unacceptable. If someone already has the game, they wouldn't be getting compensated at all.

Keep your eyes on the website Class Action Connect, people. Suits are already being written up over this.

Class action lawsuits? This case would be a waste of time and money for a law firm.

As someone who worked at one (that dealt with HUGE class actions), let me tell you, no right minded practice would take this case to court. The whole point of a class action case is that the law firm takes the legal and financial burden of running it on behalf of the people.

This case is not going to rake in huge bucks to begin with. It was a week of service disruptions and it intermittently effected people. I was not really one of them... so sweet, we can all sign up and when the case is done we get friggen 1/100000th of a penny on the dollar in about 4 years, that's once the law firm in charge is done taking their cut.

Stop whining about this stuff, be thankful they gave you a game, even if it's Yaris 2.

they really should keep track of the sales numbers, and adjust their # of servers accordingly, when a bunch get purchased. just automatically assume every single one will sign on the next day.

I already have 2 robotron, I don't want or need a 3rd. In fact, if someone wants to buy a robotron code, I have one, but I think I might keep it in case my 360 dies. So actually no you can't have it.

Not really a gift considering you paid for your service and weren't provided with it.

Like if you buy a burger and it's missing the hamburger patty.You complain and they say next time you come in, we'll give a free coke. Yes it's something, but you paid for a damn burger!

Yes, but nowhere in the service agreement does it say you get a free game. You could instead get back the cash value of lost service. 13 cents a day. So yeah, unless you missed 38 days of service (assuming a $5 game), I think it's quite a nice gift.

Probably not going to be Puzzle Quest. It is a $15 dollar game after all.
The game is worth the money though. I've put in at least 30+ hours (conservative) not to mention getting my girlfriend hooked.

If they give us some game that they don't have to pay royalties on, the cost will be lower. So some in-house game that never sold well anyway is the likely candidate...

ditto man. Just give us the points so we can choose for ourselves.

If it's Space Giraffe, I'm canceling.