Xbox 360 Fanboy

I was thinking the same thing. Some of these Xbox Live Arcade titles are insanely hard to get points on. Bejewled for one... Truth be told, the gamerscore really doesnt matter, it's the achievement itself that people should look at.

Reply

I believe points should be based on how many people currently hold the award.

In other words, if it's an award that virtually everyone who plays the game gets right away, it should be near-worthless. But if it's an award that only 20% have, it should be worth a lot of points.

This dynamic system would constantly keep people on the edge, and encourage competitivity.

Reply

You gotta give credit to Microsoft on this one... the concept of gamerscore has an addictive quality to it that encourages people to buy more and more games, just so they can boost their gamerscore.

But I, for one, am not going to buy or rent a game just so I can boost my gamerscore.

Reply

This is true, but why does it matter? It isn't as if you can use those points for anything. Now if you could transform those points into XBOX Marketplace points, then it might be a problem.

Reply

I'm sorry but maybe i'm lost on this one, but why do I care about gamescore points again?

Reply

I doubt MS would change this. Not only does it prove there gamerscore is addictive (comment 3) but it also helps sell games. Even if people rent the game, the rental stores will need copies purchased so people can rent them.

I haven't played King Kong yet, but Madden 06 is by far the easiest game to get points, minus the 400 point achievement for playing 30 years on a franchise that can be simmed.

Reply

"and even those who aren't connected now can still rack up points and plug in later to show off their skillz."

Actually that is incorrect, they must have a Live account saved on the hard drive in order to be offline and receive their gamerscore. When they login, then they get the ones that the Live system missed. If they get a new account it does not pick up ones they got before Xbox Live

Reply

When the Xbox 360 had just come out, I read a comment here that said your overall Gamerscore wasn't what mattered, but how many achievements you got per game. This guy has been proven right.

I could rent Madden, King Kong, and a few other games with easy achievements, and quickly rack up a high gamerscore. Instead, I only have PGR3 and Kameo, which dole out achievements in a more fair manner.

And yes, Bejewled achievements have got to be the most ridiculously difficult to get yet. The Endless achievement requires some 350+ hours of gameplay, and checking the leaderboards, only about two people have gotten it thusfar. That is absurd!

I agree that achievement points should depend on Xbox live leaderboards.

Reply

asurroca, if you play a game that has plenty of achievements, like PGR3 or PDZ, you will have more achievements than somoene who just plays Madden and King Kong. Madden has like 5 achievements, but PDZ and PGR3 have tons.

Reply

The reason I went out and rented King Kong & NBA2K6 was b/c I realized how easy it was to gain the points. 2K6 is even easier than Kong to rack them up with 150 points for scoring 50 in a game, 250 for grabbing 20 rebounds and getting a tripple double. I got all 1000 in one game. So yeah, they've hooked me on Achievements.

Reply

Yes gamer points are very addicting.Once you get some you cant stop.I rented king kong just for the 1000 points.You can finish the game in ONE sitting.Very easy game.

Reply

Any system where the more games you buy (the richer you are) means the more points you can get is totally flawed.
A bunch of easy points from lots of games is not equal to totally finishing a game and all its side quests and mini-games. Yet they can get the same points.

The points system is just for rich kids. Us gamers will check the achievements.

Reply

Achievement points are great, but shouldn't be given away to easily... FIFA 06 and I believe all the other EA sports titles are too easy.

If only all APs where as difficult to get as all of Duty 2... those pesky veteran levels where worth every one of my 1,000 achievement points on that game!

I wonder how difficult its going to be to get all 50 achievments on Oblivion!

Reply

I haven't really gotten into the whole gamer points thing, because they mean very little, especially to someone like me who is a casual gamer and has so few. But, like a previously commenter said, if they were somehow connected to a reward on Live (20% bonus on a one time microsoft points purchase, access to special online events, access to special gamercard features, etc.)then it would even encourage a casual gamer like myself to buy/rent games solely to rack up points.

Reply

I can sympathize with the Washington Post writer; when I finished COD2, I expected some fairly decent score, but when I saw 150, my jaw hit the floor. It was even MORE shocking because they awarded 50 points for completing the training level!

Does that mean WWII was three times as tough as basic training was? I'll go down to the VFW and ask them, in between drinks. ;->

Reply

Before the 360 launched, I read some interviews by various Microsoft employees about the gamer points. They specifically said Microsoft was supposed to level set them on each game so that 1000 points in game A would be roughly equal to 1000 points in game B.

Obviously those plans got scrapped for whatever reason. I suspect they didn't have enough time before launch.

The GRAW multiplayer achievements published earlier this week look like ridiculously hard to achieve. I kinda like that more than giving them away like candy.

Come to think of it, it'd be an interesting experiment to grade games by how easy it is to achieve gamer points in them. Right now it seems like the crappy games are extremely loose with gamer points (all sports games, King Kong, etc.), while playing the really good games will make you reall struggle to achieve gamer points.

Reply

There can be no inflation of something that has no worth. Even if you consider the bragging rights of a high gamerscore to have worth, bragging rights are alrady subject to massive inflation by those doing the bragging.

Reply

Who really cares? It's just bragging stuff anyway. I for one could care less if I have a ton of points or accomplishments posted up for all to see. It's not incentive enough for me to start playing games with 'easy points'.

Reply

Well, for some people they're for bragging. I use them to compare game progress between me and my friends.

Another neat thing I saw was in a DOA4 forum where someone was talking shit about how easy it was to unlock all the costumes and that they did it in one day. Well, someone punched up his achievements list and let him know that it was actually 5 days between his first achievement and that one.

Reply