
Game of the Year: Halo 3

Who would have thought? No really, who would have thought? Bungie outdid themselves and other developers this year with Halo 3, packing it full of features, technology and gameplay that is yet to be seen in any other game of 2007. Don't get me wrong, other gems like BioShock and Mass Effect are amazing in their own right and GOTY worthy to some, but I weigh re-playability, online functionality, community and multiplayer much higher. And surprise, surprise, Halo 3 has it all. Let's look at the list. Four player online campaign co-op with a scoring system, a delightfully satisfying story, a nearly flawless matchmaking setup, insane (crazy insane) amount of stats and data available on Bungie.net, a loyal community, screenshot and film sharing, a Theater mode and a little thing called the Forge. Oh friggin' yeah. True, it has its share of imperfections and has earned the reputation for being the whipping boy among the gaming community (people love to hate the popular), but the inconceivable amount of technology, re-playability and fun that can be had makes Halo 3 my creamy indulgence of 2007. Much love to Bungie.
XBLA Game of the Year: Carcassonne

This may be an odd choice to some, but only to those who haven't had the honor of playing this tile game-o-fun. Carcassonne is one of those rare Arcade games that perfectly packages together board game fun with enough strategy to keep things fresh every time you play. Simply put, Carcassonne has a bit of a learning curve that can never be mastered, but that's the appeal. Strategy and dancing game pieces equal greatness.
And to those of you who missed out on Carcassonne when it was a free download during LIVE is 5IVE, you should be ashamed. You missed out on a chance to experience XBLA GOTY greatness for free. Though, redemption is but 800 Microsoft points away.
Best XBLM Demo: BioShock

2K Boston (Irrational Games for purists) handled the BioShock demo release nearly perfectly. Not only did they build up enough pre-demo hype to bring Xbox Live to its knees, but the demo ended up being just enough gameplay to pull in an audience without giving away too much. 2K Boston rather smartly started off the BioShock demo exactly how the retail build did, introducing us to the world, the characters and gameplay as intended. It left me and countless others wanting more, which is exactly what a demo is supposed to do. I guess it helps that the game is hella' fun too.
Most Surprising Announcement: Peter Moore heads to EA Sports

I'm pretty sure nobody saw this coming as we were all in awe when the announcement was made that Peter Moore was leaving his Xbox 360 throne to take control of EA Sports. And our hearts have ever since been broken. We'll forever miss our Moore, his honesty and love of the platform, but it's time to move on and let go. If he's happy with his position at EA and new found million dollar fortune then I'm happy for him too. Viva la Moore!
Best XBLM Download: Rock Band's entire music library

Instead of chosing one single download I've instead picked Rock Band's entire download library as my Best XBLM Download award simply because of Harmonix's commitment and support. To be honest, I was skeptical of their weekly downloadable content promise, but so far they're batting 100 and are beating Guitar Hero III's pricing structure. Continue offering Rock Band downloads at attractive price points in a timely fashion and I'll never cheat on you Rock Band. Never ever.
Most Anticipated Game of 2008: Halo Wars, Condemned 2: Bloodshot and Castle Crashers

It's a three way tie! I couldn't narrow my Most Anticipated Game of 2008 to just one game. There are three worthy contenders that stand out in my mind and I refuse to choose. So, let's just get to them and dream about what's to come.
Halo Wars is my cautiously optimistic pick for 2008. I'm extremely interested in seeing how Ensemble Studios pulls off an RTS on the 360, but have kept my expectations rather low. No console RTS has made me a believer yet, but it's entirely possible that Halo Wars' theme alone will turn me to the dark side of console RTS gaming. We'll just have to wait and see.
Condemned 2: Bloodshot is only a few months away and I'd be a fool to say that I'm not intrigued. Monolith looks to be on track to delivering a brutally violent sequel to Criminal Origins with crisp and clean cut scenes, new gameplay tweaks and a tiny new addition called the Hobo Fight Club. Enough said.
Finally we've got one of the most anticipated XBLA games ever releasing sometime in 2008 and it's Castle Crashers. The Behemoth showed off a demo earlier this year at PAX, but with their build it, tear it apart and rebuild it again development schedule, they've pushed Castle Crashers back to an '08 release. Four player Xbox Live gaming, an inspiring art style and awkward humor make Castle Crashers a guaranteed XBLA hit. It's safe to say that these colorful knights will rule the Arcade next year.
Worst Game of the Year: Yaris

It's pretty simple. Yaris sucks! And I have never ever been so confident to say that no matter what retail or XBLA games released in 2007, Yaris takes the crown of being the Worst Game of the Year. Whoever green-lighted this mess should be slapped with a salmon, poked in the eyes with chopsticks and paraded naked down the Vegas strip with a neon sign dangling from their neck that blinks the word "idiot" every three seconds. It's like the Yaris developers took recycled sprites from some random un-released Japanese game, coded a horrible control scheme and passed it off as a "game". To hell with that. Yaris doesn't deserve the title of a real "game". I will now and forever refer to Yaris as a "chore", "torture" or a "burden" and never a "game". Funniest thing of all is that Yaris was supposed to get me and all US Live subscribers to love the Yaris vehicle brand. I now laugh at people who drive one.
That's it fanboys, those were my Best 360 Games of 2007. It was a crazy year that was full of A+ titles that left everyone's bank accounts empty and our gaming hearts satisfied. Here's to 2008 and what the video game industry will bring us, but we will always remember what we played these past twelve months. Long live the memory of gaming in 2007.
Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)
12-31-2007 @ 5:10PM
bigC24 said...
Great list, I pretty much agree with everything in it.
Reply
12-31-2007 @ 5:19PM
JakubK666 said...
Finally someone who doesn't hate Halo 3 for being a perfect Halo sequel!
Reply
12-31-2007 @ 5:21PM
OBM said...
lol @ worst game ever. Halo 3 was your favorite game Dustin? Really? that's shocking : P
Best demo is definitely BioShock, I must have played that demo 8 or 9 times.
Reply
12-31-2007 @ 5:28PM
JakubK666 said...
I would rather go for Crackdown. It broke download records and provided 10x replayability Bioshock did.
1-01-2008 @ 10:26AM
mattclarkie said...
I wasn't going to get Crackdown, but the demo was so good that I did. And I am glad of that, the game was fantastic. Although the Halo 3 Beta was a draw, the game stands out as being well executed, fun, and even replayable.
12-31-2007 @ 5:27PM
Big Ed said...
inb4 Call of Duty fanboys
Reply
12-31-2007 @ 5:39PM
Phil said...
OMGWTFBBQ! C0d4 iz deffineteli teh bezt g4m3 evar! Stoopid Hal0 fanboiz!
Seriously I like Call of Duty 4 a little bit more than Halo. But I miss saved films so much when I play Call of Duty :)
12-31-2007 @ 5:39PM
Robert said...
Thank you Dustin. Couldn't agree more about GotY.
Reply
12-31-2007 @ 5:43PM
Dragod said...
I agree on Halo 3.. I haven't played any other game as much as I have Halo 3, except Halo 2, and I'm catching up to it fast. I literally just got off of a 4 hour forge session, and I'm not even done. I still have to add my weapon spawns and everything.
It seems that people just want to hate Halo because it's popular. People say "Ugh, it's horrible", but look at the sales numbers. Then, look at the amount of unique players in a day.
I'm still not bored with it either. Forge has added several hours a day I can play, I'm still working on Legendary campaign, and I'm working on getting my level 42 in Lone Wolves to level 45. There's plenty to do, while I haven't even touched CoD4 in 2 weeks.
And for all of those people who say CoD4 is better, I disagree. It's a good game, a damn good game, but it's always the same old same old. But it seems like winning and losing is more weighted to those who have the better weapons. If someone has a 50 cal sniper, you're screwed assuming they're a decent shot. If they have a carbine, you're not really worried.
In Halo, every weapon has a way to beat the others. A sniper can take out a lot of people if they do it fast, but as soon as someone pulls out a Battle Rifle and hits the sniper, the BR's got the upper hand.
Halo is just more polished and balanced. Every person can use the same weapons and have an equal chance at getting them, meaning it relies more on skill than the weapon you've unlocked.
Reply
12-31-2007 @ 7:32PM
nayrnedlog said...
I have to disagree with you Dragod on your comment about how COD4 relies on the weapon more than skill, i recently got the game for christmas and i had played the Beta what seems like a long time ago. With my crappy ass weapons I have been top of the board everytime. Granted I love FPS and thats all I do.
For the record i still enjoy Halo more.
12-31-2007 @ 8:59PM
Urza said...
And if you pull out an assault rifle and start shooting the sniper, the sniper dies right away.. unlike halo.
I think you haven't played enough CoD4.
I love both games.
1-01-2008 @ 1:21AM
Dragod said...
Oh no, I love the games. But to me, Halo is a more competitive game. It's like Halo is the competitive fast-paced Shooter, Gears of War is the suspenseful tactical shooter, while CoD4 is in the middle as a semi-tactical medium to fast paced shooter.
Trust me, I love all 3 games. I know that in CoD4 you can till dominate with the crappier weapons, but they are much less balanced. In Halo, it's about strafing, using cover, and using the right combination of weapons. CoD4 is about staking out, camping then popping out at the right moment.
I dunno. I'm a a big fan of the Call of Duty franchise (Played nothing but CoD2 and Halo 2 when I first got my 360 until Gears came out), but it seemed like CoD4 was trying to compete, rather than innovate. What's up with the metagame? Bungie announces the metagame in Halo 3, then a few weeks later it's in CoD4? Seemed kind of like "Quick, they added this, let's add it too".
But honestly, I think Halo did everything better. 4 player online co-op is amazing, Forge has added hours and hours of replayability, the Multiplayer can't be beat, the fanbase is astounding, the quality of DLC is amazing, saved films and file sharing is something I'd like to see in every game, and Bungie.net allows me to track every single stat I could possibly want to look up, and even ones I don't need? It's cool to see that I kill 1.2 people for every time I die, it's great that I can compare tenths of a percent between me and my friends and I can say "Wow, I need to work on so-and-so if I want to be as good as you in this or that map".
People say Halo 3 was a disappointment, but I ask "What else could you possibly want?". Honestly, what does Call of Duty have that Halo doesn't? They're different games, and I understand that people look for different things in games, but I don't think anyone can say that Halo 3 is a bad game or that it was a disappointment. I couldn't be happier.
1-02-2008 @ 9:47AM
TORO said...
I like both Halo 3 and COD 4, but many of my friends switched from Halo to COD mainly because Team Slayer is too difficult to compete in. I'm pretty good at Halo, but my friends (and girlfriend) rather play COD where they have a better chance to kill someone.
12-31-2007 @ 5:53PM
www.PSvsXBOX.com said...
I like the list too, but Gears Of War is the winner for me as Game of the year. Ahhh... so many sleepless nights battling my buddies.
Reply
12-31-2007 @ 5:59PM
Dragod said...
Gears came out last year (2006) ;)
12-31-2007 @ 6:03PM
www.PSvsXBOX.com said...
That's right! Sorry about that.
12-31-2007 @ 6:07PM
joetron2030 said...
I'm going to be picky about it and suggest that you meant "batting 1.000 (i.e. 1,000) and not batting 100".
Reply
1-01-2008 @ 9:13AM
Erik J. Barzeski said...
You beat me to it.
12-31-2007 @ 6:08PM
Triforceowner said...
Could you guys get David to write one of these as well, seeing as he was on staff for the majority of 2007 and did state he wouldn't completely abandon Xbox 360 Fanboy?
Reply
12-31-2007 @ 6:08PM
Arnie said...
I cant believe as Xbox360 fanboys we are forgetting GTA4 as one of the most anticipated games of 2008. Also on my list are Age of Conan:Hyborian Adventures, Alan Wake and Fable 2(the last two only have tentative schedules for 2008)
Another great great game which is flying pretty much under the radar right now for 2008 is Tom Clancy's:End War which has voice controls!!! thats like the best way to control in RTS games. I can not wait for the online games in that one.
ALso, Mass Effect rocks and is fun as hell except for the elevator riding which just pisses me off!!
Reply